News

English PEN and Index on Censorship give evidence to the Leveson Inquiry

A statutory backstop for press regulation could damage freedom of speech, the Leveson Inquiry has heard.Jonathan Heawood, director of English PEN, a charity supporting free expression, told the inquiry co-regulation was a veiled form of statutory regulation, and said he had never seen a model incorporating the best of self-regulation and state intervention.He said: "One would rather live in a too noisy society than in a quiet, over-regulated society".He added: “You may encounter the Desmond problem where some publishers choose not to opt in. I think ultimately that’s preferable and to subscribe and be a member of that code becomes a badge of honour. I haven’t yet seen a model which charts a magical course between those two routes”.Heawood was questioned with John Kampfner, chief executive of Index on Censorship, who said there is no such thing as a perfect system of regulation.Kampfner said he saw “no need” for statutory regulation of the media, and championed a robust system encouraging ethical editorial practice.He said a strong independent framework of self-regulation continuing the complaint and mediation work of the PCC, but with a strong standards arm, would benefit the press. He added the PCC code “needs tweaking” and serving editors should not be able to sit on the board.He added: “I would simply argue that there have been many last chance saloons before but with the right robust and considerable changes…[we could have] a strong system of self-regulation”.Heawood said the Guardian “have blazed a trail” in appointing an internal ombudsman, readers’ editor Chris Elliot, who gave evidence to the inquiry last week, to resolve complaints quickly and effectively.

Download the full report:

Download report

Queries: campaign@hackinginquiry.org

related Posts

New podcast, Everyone’s Still Hacked Off, debuts on Spotify
Hacked Off's new podcast is now available on Spotify.
6/17/25
News
"The Little Black Book of Press Barons": New book details how media moguls shape our news and how we reclaim it
New book by Matthew Gallagher, Jonathan Heawood, Emma Jones, and Kyle Taylor exposes the control that powerful individuals have over the press, and how to hold them accountable.
5/22/25
News